Vocalic Equivalance

if a sound-formation is totally open then it is vowel then if we introduce a bit of constraint, it becomes an approximant consonant.

Vocalic equivalent between ɑ: and ʕ̞

The open back unrounded vowel (represented as [ɑ], similar to the "a" sound in "father") is produced by lowering the tongue and pulling the tongue root back toward the throat (pharynx). If you narrow that pharyngeal space just a fraction more, the vowel transitions into a pharyngeal approximant [ʕ̞].
So, phonetically, [ʕ̞] has just enough narrowing in the pharynx to be classed as a consonant, whereas [ɑ] keeps the pharynx open enough to remain a pure vowel.
When linguists say that [ɑ] is the vocalic equivalent of [ʕ̞], they mean these two sounds share the exact same active articulators—namely, the tongue root backing toward the pharyngeal wall—just set at slightly different distances.
Vocalic Equivalance


But why not call all approximants as vowel?

Articulation Site 📍 Vowel (Syllable Core) 🎵 Approximant (Syllable Edge) 🛑
Palatal (Front/Hard Palate) [i] (like in see) [j] (like 'y' in yes)
Labial-Velar (Lips/Soft Palate) [u] (like in too) [w] (like 'w' in win)
Pharyngeal (Throat) [ɑ] (like in father) [ʕ̞] (pharyngeal approximant)